I bought the newer nickel-plated option thinking it will completely remove spring crunch, but in reality it's more of a 30-40% improvement in feel after oiling compared to stock topre springs.
You can feel the crunching if you squeeze the springs between your fingers or on a surface mimicking real use. Drenching the springs in 105g0 removes most of the crunch, but it eventually comes back once the oil spreads to the domes and pcb. Astrodomes hide the crunch the most but I highly recommend leaving the domes stuck to the pcb if your topre keyboard is still stock. I'm currently testing these in the latest generation silenced fc660c and I know for sure the springs didn't crunch before I took off the domes (although they did tick when releasing from a holding bottom out but that's a whole separate issue I'm talking to talk at this point). I also compared the feel with a hhkb pro 2 type s that didn't have its domes separated from the pcb and trust me the typing experience of the hhkb is a lot better.
10/10 packaging though with the separated springs, but it doesn't matter anyway because lube is NOT optional.